Question
Civility and Freedom Discussion #2
on
Ronson's "How One Stupid Tweet Blew Up Justine Sacco's Life"
describes the internet shaming that Justine Sacco faced following a 2013 tweet.
For your discussion, identify another internet shaming incident. This may be an
incident that made the news or one that you witnessed on social media. Complete
the chart below using Ronson's text to compare your selection to Sacco's. Then
compose two to three paragraphs that summarize the
information from all three columns. Focus on paraphrasing! Include an MLA style
in-text citations and Works Cited entries for all three sources. 1. Elaborate
on the ideas in your chart in one of two ways: Compose 2-3 paragraphs that
explain the similarities between Ronson's example of internet shaming and your
example https://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/15/magazine/how-one-stupid-tweet-ruined-justine-saccos-life.html
Expert Solution
|
|
Ronson's Selection |
My Selection |
Explain how the Sacco incident and your
selection reconnected |
|
|
Who initiated this incident? |
Justine Sacco |
Jennifer Kim |
The two posts raised online criticism and
resulted in the disappearance of the posters from the internet. |
|
|
What made this social media post offensive to
others? |
The racial discriminative nature of the post |
Kim was complaining about the lost violin in
an accident that had claimed eight lives and left more than 200 people
hospitalized for injuries. |
|
|
|
What was the poster's Response to criticism? |
She tried to hide from the internet shaming,
and her friend Hannah deleted the post and her account. |
Kim did not respond to the criticism but kept
off the internet. |
|
|
|
What is your response to this incident? |
It was wrong for Justine to make such a post.
The post was discriminative against the Africans, and he acted to be superior
because she was White. |
It was unethical for Kim to complain about a
mere issue like a violin despite the loss of lives and injuries. The post
revealed the brutal nature of the poster. |
|
|
ustine's internet post during the holidays in 2013 about her visit to Africa and how she could not get affected with AIDS because she was White. Her post was discriminative against Africans and attracted criticism all over Twitter (Ronson). Justine could not imagine landing in Africa after the post went trending. She hid from the public because she feared people's response to her post. Her Twitter post and account were deleted by her friend Hannah.
Jennifer's internet post after her survival in an accident attracted a lot of criticism. Despite losing eight people and leaving many others injured after the accident, Jennifer could dare post on Twitter about her lost violin Worland. The post angered people, but she did not reply to the critics. Her post was deleted, and her Twitter account was closed due to the negative public response.Both Justine and Jennifer's Twitter posts received public shaming because of their nature of messages. The rise of technology has enabled people to capture and upload their daily occurrences (Muir et al., 1). The two have negative impressions of what society perceives to be ethical. Both saw the closure of the Twitter accounts from the internet to discourage such posts.
Works Cited
Muir S, Roberts L and Sheridan L “The Portrayal of Online Shaming in Contemporary Online News Media: A Media Framing Analysis” (2021)
Ronson
Jon "How One Stupid Tweet Blew Up Justine Sacco's Life" (2015)
Available: https://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/15/magazine/how-one-stupid-tweet-ruined-justine-saccos-life.html
Worland
Justine "Survivor's Tweet About Violin Lost in Amtrak Crash Sparks
Outrage" (2015) Available: https://time.com/3856993/amtrak-lost-violin/
Please enter your email address to h
- 100% Plagiarism-free
- 100% Human-written
