In
our lessons, your learned that the United States says it does not have to
submit to the United Nations' rules and oversight because the United States
already respects human rights. It commonly is said that "human rights are
as American as apple pie." While it seems to be a silly quote, what it
captures is that human rights are meant to be part of America's creed. The
United States reminds us that our nation literally sprung from notions of
"human rights". But, a review of history reveals that human rights
simply have not been applied to all. Most commonly, we recognize the history of
oppression suffered by African Americans. But, in the lessons for 10/5, you
examined the history of Native oppression. While you might have heard about this
history in a general sense, little discussion occurs in the United States
regarding the true extent of Native genocide.
The
destruction of Natives extended beyond the killing, and extends to the taking
of their religion and even "Native" or "Indigenous"
identity itself. These examples are aplenty. You now can earn points by showing
you can use these examples to explore how the United States has violated the
same "human rights" doctrines it requires of other nations.
Instructions
1) Consider our lessons on the human rights
doctrines (see UDHR and the covenants)
2)
Choose three (3) of the below human rights of interest to you. To learn more
about the right, read the Textbook chapter. (the book can be accessed here)
Textbook: Human Rights - A Short History: -- Chapter 4- Torture -- Chapter 5-
Deprivations of life and liberty --Chapter 6- Speech and Belief --Chapter 7-
Food, education, health, housing, and work --Chapter 8 – Discrimination and
equality
3)
Watch or read about (you don't have to do both), Native history from the
lessons for 10/5. As you watch, apply your understanding to these chapters by
finding an example for at least three (3) each of the below human rights:
Textbook: Human Rights - A Short History: -- Chapter 4- Torture -- Chapter 5-
Deprivations of life and liberty --Chapter 6- Speech and Belief --Chapter 7-
Food, education, health, housing, and work --Chapter 8 – Discrimination and
equality
4) In approx. 500-750 words (1 - 1 1/2 pages
if single spaced), use specifically cited references and explanations from
each: the documentaries or textbook regarding history, supporting materials,
and our course lessons, to address each (note, you can answer it in one
combined essay, or separated into each short-answer): For each of the three (3)
human rights you choose answer:
(4a)
For the first human right you chose from the above list, answer
(4ai) List the human right
(4aii)
Show you understood that human right by describing it briefly (a few sentences)
in your own words. Do not just cut and paste from the internet, you must
specifically cite our course materials.
(4aiii) In about a paragraph or two, describe at least one (1) scene or scenario from the textbook or video where Natives were denied that right. Your answer cannot just generally say "Natives were discriminated against" or "Natives were killed." To earn points, you must do both:
(4aiii-1) Prove you watched the
documentary or read the textbook by describing the scenario you are applying
that right to. (to illustrate: "In the Trail of Tears video, there was a
scene showing children and elderly people unable to walk through the snow being
left on the side of the road to die....")
(4aiii-2) You must explain how you are applying that human right to that scene. (to illustrate: "Being forced to walk miles through the snow is torture under the United Nations' Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment because according to Chap. 4 of Short History, nations cannot do ....") (4b) For example 2, answer each of the questions
(4ai-aiii) (4c) For example 3, answer each of the questions (4ai-aiii) This means, there are three sets of answers, one for each of the human rights violations you identify in Native history (as evidenced by the videos or textbook). Grading Criteria Check to see you have answered all parts of the question. You are challenged to:
1)
explore those "entitlements"/rights that the United Nations claims to
protect (e.g., right not to be
tortured);
2)
illustrate the depth of your understanding by explaining how these rights could
exist across settings - applying it to Native history,
3)
form an opinion about what the violations tells you about US Policies on Human
Right,
4) explain and support your position using specific references to the course materials. You are required to review all the Native history in our lesson 10/5, but you can choose to learn the history using the videos or textbook (you are not required to do both). Regardless of whichever you choose, you do not need to keep detailed notes on every name or date. But you will want to be able to generally describe specific scenes to support your opinion. There is no "correct" answer or response. Do not feel the need to master the topic or conduct extensive outside research. Rather, your answer should reflect your ability to: Recall and retrieve relevant knowledge from your course material; Recognize pertinent examples that specifically illustrate your understanding of the example you chose. You must decide which examples are relevant and apply to the problem. Critically analyze the course materials by making and explaining the connections between concepts and historical accounts. The more on-point your example is, the greater your points; Summarize and highlight the main points briefly. Duplicate, irrelevant, inaccurate, and/or loosely-related excerpts will affect your grade. More than a citation to the course materials is required. You must explain the example/excerpt in your own words so we know how the lesson is being applied.
Torture
Torture is against the United
Nations covenant, but the US government has, in most cases, been on record for
violating human rights. Torture is an act of subjecting an individual to
suffering to extract confessions and get actual proof to be used for their
convictions at trial (Clapham, 2007). Despite the common law prohibiting
torture, the king allowed it to torture people under a particular procedure. An
example is torture was in 1605 when Guy Fawkes was caught trying to blow up the
House of Parliament (Clapham, 2007). Fawkes was tortured into giving the name
of the accomplices.
Deprived
of Life and Liberty
Human beings have a right to
life and liberty, and the US government is mandated to ensure that everyone
enjoys that right. Deprived life implies the actions that might lead to the
loss of life of a human being Clapham, 2007. Deprived liberty implies a lack of
freedom to do the right thing in the country, but people are restricted from
doing what the official perceives as wrong. An example of the violation of this
right is the use of excessive power by a police officer who shoots criminals
even when their lives are not threatened (Clapham, 2007). Such a victim is
denied the right to live and the freedom to enjoy human rights.
Speech and Belief
The right to speech ad belief
gives people the right to express themselves and follow their beliefs. The
right gives people the leeway to express their opinions and hold onto their
beliefs as human beings (Clapham, 2007). The law has been violated, especially
when a person is criticizing the government through expressions of frustration
(Clapham, 2007). The right to belief is denied when aspects like religion are
restricted by the government forcing people to follow certain beliefs.
References
Clapham, A (2007) Human Rights: A Very Short Introduction. Oxford
Univerity Press