Question
Tied to the Track’ Case Study
Please choose any ONE of the three case studies that we have encountered so far during the course:
Case Study 1: Good Sports and Winners
Case Study 2: Tied to the Track
Case Study 3: Miles and Miles and Miles
Case Study 4: Lots of Rules and No Mercy
In a 500-750 word essay, [1] identify the central ethical issue in your chosen case study and [2] identify the courses of action that could be taken to resolve the problem at the heart of your chosen case. Please make the strongest case you can for whichever resolution you would personally advocate for. To do so, please imagine that you're talking to someone who knows very little about the matter at hand, but has a strong opinion on it (that happens to be the opposite of yours). Assume that they don't share your relevant defining features (e.g., socioeconomic status, race, ethnicity, religious beliefs or lack thereof, etc.). What do you say in order to convince them of the merit of your preferred course of action? A good Case Study Assignment essay will involve preemptively responding to some of the concerns of your imagined interlocutor in good faith and respectfully, relying on reasons as opposed to merely feelings or intuitions. I have copy and past tired of the track The common image of a great athlete is of someone who works hard, makes healthy life decisions, treats their teammates, coaches, officials, and opponents with respect, and wins only by doing their best while encouraging others to do the same. From this image, athletes are often revered as individuals who have developed good character through the teachings of sports, which are often referred to as the "life lessons" of sports. The potential to develop good character from sports is sought by many, but good sportsmanship is a cornerstone in one's development. To practice good sportsmanship, an athlete must play for the sake of the game, respect the rules, respect their opponents, and encourage their teammates and competitors to do their best. In competition, they only win by working hard and doing their best. Sportsmanship differs from gamesmanship, which encourages "winning at all costs." Furthermore, rule-breaking is often considered to be cheating only when the rule-breaker gets caught. Athletes are generally praised for good sportsmanship and criticized for gamesmanship, but this does not seem to be enough to prevent the latter. While it ought to be the case that players, coaches, and spectators should be able to express disagreement, it is common for some critiques to go too far, or take place despite being obviously unfounded. Rowdy spectators, as well as athletes faking fouls and intentionally taking out their competitors to gain an advantage, often put sports competitions in a negative light. To challenge these unsportsmanlike behaviors, some organizations, such as the Eastern New York Soccer Association, have begun to emphasize the importance of good sportsmanship in their youth leagues. The goal of this program is to support good character development. Other actions to encourage accountability for bad sportsmanship have been taken by other programs as well. For instance, USA Today: High School Sports reported on January 8, 2022, that the head coach of the Sacred Heart Academy's girls' basketball team in Connecticut was suspended in the winter of 2022 for running up the score in a game that the team won by a score of 92-4. Such efforts to inspire sportsmanship and suppress gamesmanship benefit athletes by supporting good character development. However, other athletic organizations seem to be moving away from sportsmanship and towards gamesmanship. There is a greater cultural desire for competition that is fast and lively. Slower sports like baseball have experienced a decline in spectators as a result. The baseball community has to add the "pie-slice rule," which prohibits infielders from being near the second base area prior to a pitch. The "pie-slice rule" is meant to encourage athletes to move more on the bases, rather than only trying to hit home runs. Whether or not the "pie-slice rule" will change the athletic conduct of baseball, its inclusion seems designed to bolster interest in the sport. Other sports have also adjusted their rules to capture a greater audience. The XFL is a professional football league that strives to be progressive and forward thinking about how football is played. The rules of the XFL are a bit different from the NFL. Specifically, XFL rules encourage faster and more violent games the kind of games that fans want to see. This league is also known for its overhyped fanfare and oversexualized cheerleaders. While the XFL lost momentum during the COVID-19 pandemic it is set to be relaunched in 2023 and the XFL league managers intend to form partnerships with other professional football leagues to lead the way in changing how football culture and game laws progress into the future.
Expert Solution
The
"Tied to the Track" case study revolves around harmonizing good
sportsmanship and gamesmanship during athletic contests. Good sportsmanship is
concerned with the promotion of fair play, respect for competitors, and the
development of characters and talents (Ludwiczak and Bronikowska, 2022). Gamesmanship on the other
hand, concentrate on triumphing at all costs, frequently through unethical mean
encompassing fouling, cheating, or even engaging in unsportsmanlike behavior.
This question has been solved!
- Verified by Admin
- Written by a Human Expert
